Go to content
Skip menu
Skip menu
OCIMF TMSA 3 — Tanker Management & Self Assessment

TMSA 3 Explained: Tanker Management and Self-Assessment

The OCIMF Tanker Management and Self Assessment programme, commonly known as TMSA, provides tanker operators with a structured framework for evaluating the effectiveness of their management systems. The third edition, TMSA 3, introduced revised assessment requirements, expanded best-practice guidance, 13 elements and 266 Key Performance Indicators (KPIs), supporting systematic evaluation and continuous improvement across tanker operations.

Understanding the OCIMF TMSA Programme

The Tanker Management and Self Assessment programme was developed by the Oil Companies International Marine Forum (OCIMF) to encourage tanker operators to assess the effectiveness of their management systems against defined industry expectations and recommended practices.

TMSA provides a structured method for reviewing management processes ashore and their implementation onboard vessels. It covers a broad range of operational and organizational responsibilities, including leadership, personnel management, vessel reliability, navigation, cargo operations, safety, environmental performance, emergency preparedness and maritime security.

The programme is based on self-assessment. Operators evaluate their own systems against the relevant KPIs and supporting best-practice guidance, identify areas requiring improvement and develop actions to strengthen management-system performance.

Important distinction: TMSA is a voluntary management-system self-assessment framework. It is not a statutory certificate, classification approval or substitute for mandatory audits and regulatory requirements.

What Is TMSA 3?

TMSA 3 is the third edition of OCIMF's Tanker Management and Self Assessment programme. Published in April 2017, it updated the previous framework to improve clarity, consistency and the practical application of the assessment process.

The third edition retained the established TMSA structure while expanding and revising the supporting best-practice guidance. It also introduced a new maritime security element and additional KPIs addressing developments in tanker management and industry practice.

13 Assessment Elements

The TMSA 3 framework is organised into 13 numbered management elements. Element 6 is further divided into operational sections 6 and 6A.

266 Key Performance Indicators

The third edition contains 266 KPIs, providing structured assessment criteria across the different areas of tanker management.

Four Assessment Levels

Each KPI is assessed through four progressive levels, providing a framework for evaluating management-system development and maturity.

Continuous Improvement

The framework encourages operators to identify weaknesses, evaluate performance and implement improvements over time.

Main Changes Introduced in TMSA 3

The third edition introduced a number of changes intended to improve the assessment process and reflect developments in legislation, operational practice and tanker management expectations.

Expanded Best-Practice Guidance Additional guidance was introduced to support interpretation of the KPIs and improve consistency in self-assessment.
Improved Clarity Existing guidance was revised to reduce ambiguity and duplication within the assessment framework.
Revised Elements 6 and 6A Cargo, ballast, tank cleaning, bunkering, mooring and anchoring operations received additional KPIs and best-practice guidance.
Environmental and Energy Management Element 10 was revised to include energy management and energy-efficiency considerations.
New Maritime Security Element Element 13 was introduced to address maritime security within the tanker management assessment framework.
Removal of Not Applicable Option TMSA 3 removed the option to mark individual KPIs as not applicable.
Additional KPIs The third edition introduced 85 new KPIs and contains 19 more KPIs than the second edition.
Revised Assessment Stages Twenty-five KPIs were moved from a higher assessment level to a lower one, supporting the programme's continuous improvement approach.

The 13 Elements of TMSA 3

TMSA 3 is structured around 13 numbered elements covering the principal management responsibilities of a tanker operating organization. The elements address shore-based management, vessel operations, personnel, safety, technical reliability, environmental performance and security.

The following list follows the TMSA 3 element structure. Element 6A is shown separately because it addresses mooring and anchoring operations within the Element 6 operational framework.

Element 1 — Leadership and the Safety Management System Leadership, management commitment and the development, implementation and maintenance of the company's Safety Management System.
Element 2 — Recruitment and Management of Shore-Based Personnel Recruitment, competence, development and management of personnel working within the shore-based organization.
Element 3 — Recruitment, Management and Wellbeing of Vessel Personnel Recruitment, management, competence and wellbeing of personnel serving onboard the company's vessels.
Element 4 — Vessel Reliability and Maintenance Including Critical Equipment Technical management, planned maintenance, vessel reliability and the management of critical equipment.
Element 5 — Navigational Safety Navigation management, bridge procedures, navigational practices and the controls supporting safe vessel navigation.
Element 6 — Cargo, Ballast, Tank Cleaning and Bunkering Operations Management and control of cargo handling, ballast operations, tank cleaning and bunkering activities.
Element 6A — Mooring and Anchoring Operations Management of mooring and anchoring activities, including operational procedures, equipment and associated risks.
Element 7 — Management of Change Identification, assessment and control of changes that may affect personnel, vessels, equipment or management systems.
Element 8 — Incident Reporting, Investigation and Analysis Reporting, investigation and analysis of incidents, including the identification of causes and application of lessons learned.
Element 9 — Safety Management Implementation and monitoring of safety-management practices and operational controls throughout the organization.
Element 10 — Environmental and Energy Management Environmental protection, pollution prevention, energy management and the monitoring of environmental performance.
Element 11 — Emergency Preparedness and Contingency Planning Emergency planning, preparedness, response arrangements and contingency-management procedures.
Element 12 — Measurement, Analysis and Improvement Measurement of performance, analysis of management-system results and implementation of improvement activities.
Element 13 — Maritime Security Identification and management of maritime security risks affecting vessels, personnel and operations.
Element structure: TMSA 3 has 13 numbered elements. Element 6A is an additional separately identified operational section associated with Element 6. The assessment structure therefore includes both cargo-related and mooring and anchoring operational requirements.

Understanding TMSA 3 KPIs

Key Performance Indicators are the principal assessment criteria used within TMSA 3. They provide a structured means of evaluating whether the operator's management arrangements and practices meet the expectations described in the programme.

The 266 KPIs are distributed across the 13 elements. Each KPI is associated with an assessment level and supporting best-practice guidance. Operators use the criteria to review their existing arrangements and determine the level supported by their actual procedures, records and implementation evidence.

Documented Arrangements

Assessment should consider whether suitable policies, procedures and management arrangements have been established for the relevant activity.

Practical Implementation

Documented procedures should be supported by evidence that the arrangements are implemented in practice, both ashore and onboard where applicable.

Performance Monitoring

Operators should evaluate whether their systems are monitored and whether the results provide meaningful information about operational and management performance.

Improvement Evidence

Evidence of review, corrective action and improvement helps demonstrate that the organization is evaluating and developing its management systems.

Assessment principle: A procedure or document alone does not necessarily demonstrate effective implementation. The operator should be able to support its self-assessment with appropriate evidence reflecting actual management practices and operational performance.

The Four TMSA 3 Assessment Levels

TMSA 3 uses four progressive assessment levels for its KPIs. The levels provide a framework for evaluating the development and maturity of management practices, from the initial expectations through increasingly advanced practices.

Level 1 — Initial Expectations Represents the minimum expectations associated with the relevant KPI and provides the foundation for the operator's management arrangements.
Level 2 — Further Development Represents a further stage of development, requiring additional management practices and supporting evidence beyond the initial level.
Level 3 — More Advanced Practices Represents a higher degree of management-system development, implementation and performance evaluation.
Level 4 — Highest Assessment Stage Represents the highest stage within the four-level assessment structure, reflecting more advanced management practices and continuous improvement.

The four levels are progressive, but the detailed expectations differ between individual KPIs. Operators should therefore consult the applicable TMSA 3 KPI and its associated best-practice guidance rather than applying a single generic interpretation to every element.

Important: The four assessment levels should not be interpreted as a certification grading system. The operator is responsible for conducting its self-assessment and ensuring that its selected level is supported by appropriate evidence.

How the TMSA 3 Self-Assessment Works

TMSA 3 is based on the operator's evaluation of its own management systems. The self-assessment process should involve relevant departments and personnel who understand the company's procedures, operational responsibilities and actual implementation onboard and ashore.

1. Review the Applicable KPI

Examine the relevant element, KPI and supporting best-practice guidance to understand the assessment expectations.

2. Evaluate Existing Arrangements

Review company procedures, responsibilities, records, operational controls and existing management practices.

3. Examine Supporting Evidence

Consider whether documented arrangements are implemented and supported by appropriate records and operational evidence.

4. Determine the Assessment Level

Evaluate the available evidence against the requirements of the relevant KPI and determine the level that can reasonably be supported.

5. Identify Gaps

Record weaknesses, incomplete arrangements and areas where implementation or evidence requires improvement.

6. Establish Improvement Actions

Assign responsibilities, establish appropriate actions and monitor progress through the company's management review process.

TMSA 3 Evidence and Documentation

Evidence is an important part of a meaningful TMSA self-assessment. The operator should be able to demonstrate that its management arrangements are not only documented but also implemented and monitored.

The type of evidence required depends on the applicable KPI and the company's operational arrangements. Evidence may include documented procedures, management records, performance reports, training records, inspection findings, audit results and records of corrective or improvement actions.

Management Documentation Policies, procedures, manuals, instructions and defined responsibilities supporting the relevant management process.
Operational Records Records demonstrating how procedures and controls are applied during vessel and shore-based operations.
Training and Competence Records Records supporting personnel qualifications, competence, training and development.
Monitoring and Review Records Performance reports, management reviews, internal reviews and other records demonstrating monitoring and evaluation.
Incident and Investigation Records Incident reports, investigation findings, root-cause evaluations and lessons-learned records.
Corrective and Improvement Actions Records showing identified weaknesses, assigned actions, implementation progress and follow-up review.
Evidence quality: Evidence should be relevant to the KPI being assessed, sufficiently current and representative of actual company practice. Documentation should not be treated as a substitute for effective implementation.

TMSA 3 and the Management of Tanker Operations

TMSA 3 connects a wide range of management responsibilities. Its practical application requires coordination between shore-based departments, vessel personnel and senior management.

Shore-Based Management

Management responsibilities include policies, personnel arrangements, technical support, operational oversight, performance monitoring and management review.

Vessel Operations

Vessel operations require effective implementation of procedures covering navigation, cargo handling, maintenance, safety and emergency preparedness.

Technical Management

Technical management supports vessel reliability, machinery maintenance, critical equipment management and control of technical risks.

Personnel and Competence

Personnel management addresses recruitment, competence, training, development and the wellbeing of shore-based and vessel personnel.

Safety and Environmental Management

Management systems should support safe operations, pollution prevention, environmental protection and appropriate operational risk controls.

Performance and Improvement

Monitoring, analysis, incident investigation and management review support the identification of weaknesses and improvement opportunities.

Common Challenges During TMSA 3 Implementation

Effective TMSA implementation requires more than completing an assessment or maintaining a collection of documents. Operators may encounter difficulties when management procedures, operational practices and supporting evidence are not adequately aligned.

Incomplete KPI Understanding Misinterpretation of individual KPIs or their associated best-practice guidance can result in inconsistent self-assessment.
Insufficient Supporting Evidence Management arrangements may exist but lack suitable records demonstrating implementation and effectiveness.
Shore and Vessel Disconnect Procedures developed ashore may not be consistently understood or implemented onboard vessels.
Unclear Responsibilities Responsibilities for KPI assessment, evidence collection and improvement actions may not be clearly allocated.
Weak Performance Monitoring Performance indicators may be recorded without sufficient analysis or management evaluation.
Insufficient Follow-Up Identified gaps may remain unresolved where corrective actions lack ownership, monitoring or management review.

Relationship Between TMSA 3 and OCIMF SIRE 2.0

TMSA and SIRE 2.0 are related but separate OCIMF programmes. They provide different perspectives on tanker management and operational performance.

TMSA focuses on the company's management systems and the effectiveness of its organizational arrangements. SIRE 2.0 is a vessel inspection programme that evaluates vessel condition, operational practices and the application of procedures during an inspection.

TMSA 3

Evaluates the operator's management systems, organizational arrangements, leadership, personnel management, technical management, risk controls and continuous improvement.

SIRE 2.0

Provides a structured vessel inspection process focusing on the vessel, its equipment, operational practices and the competence and performance demonstrated during inspection activities.

Complementary relationship: Effective management systems should support consistent onboard implementation. Operational observations and inspection findings can also provide useful information for reviewing and improving the operator's management arrangements.

TMSA does not replace SIRE 2.0, and a TMSA self-assessment does not constitute a vessel inspection. Operators should understand the separate purpose and requirements of each programme.

Continuous Improvement Under TMSA 3

Continuous improvement is a central principle of the TMSA programme. The purpose of self-assessment is not simply to record an assessment level, but to evaluate the effectiveness of management systems and identify opportunities for further development.

Regular Review

Management systems and supporting evidence should be reviewed to determine whether they remain appropriate for the company's operations.

Performance Evaluation

Performance information should be analysed to identify trends, recurring weaknesses and areas requiring management attention.

Corrective Action

Identified deficiencies should be evaluated and addressed through suitable corrective actions with defined responsibilities.

Management Oversight

Management should review progress and evaluate whether improvement actions are achieving their intended results.

Continuous improvement principle: The value of TMSA lies in the effective evaluation and development of management systems, supported by evidence and practical implementation rather than assessment documentation alone.

Independent Technical Consultancy and TMSA Improvement

An independent technical review can provide tanker operators with an objective perspective on the implementation of their management systems and the evidence supporting their TMSA self-assessment.

The scope of such support may include review of selected KPIs, examination of relevant procedures and records, identification of potential gaps and evaluation of corrective or improvement actions.

TMSA Gap Assessment

Review of selected TMSA elements and KPIs to identify potential differences between existing arrangements and the applicable assessment expectations.

Management-System Review

Technical examination of relevant procedures, records and implementation arrangements to evaluate consistency between documented systems and operational practice.

Evidence Review

Review of available supporting documentation and records to identify potential evidence weaknesses within the agreed assessment scope.

Corrective-Action Review

Evaluation of identified gaps and proposed improvement actions, including responsibilities, implementation arrangements and follow-up considerations.

Independence and responsibility: Independent consultancy can support an operator's review and improvement process. The operator remains responsible for its management systems, TMSA self-assessment, assessment decisions and any submission through the applicable OCIMF programme.

TMSA and Statutory Compliance

TMSA provides a management-system framework that complements statutory and regulatory obligations. It does not replace international conventions, flag State requirements, class requirements or mandatory management-system obligations.

Tanker operators must continue to maintain compliance with applicable international and national requirements, including relevant obligations under the International Safety Management (ISM) Code and other applicable maritime instruments.

A sound TMSA implementation should therefore be considered alongside the operator's statutory compliance responsibilities, vessel-specific operational requirements and applicable industry guidance.

Key TMSA 3 Considerations for Tanker Operators

Management-system effectiveness: TMSA 3 should be approached as an ongoing evaluation of how effectively the company's management systems operate. A meaningful assessment requires consistency between procedures, personnel responsibilities, operational implementation, performance monitoring and supporting evidence.

Operators should avoid treating TMSA as a documentation exercise or as an isolated annual activity. Its value depends on management involvement, objective assessment, appropriate evidence and effective follow-up of identified weaknesses.

Conclusion

OCIMF TMSA 3 provides tanker operators with a structured framework for assessing management-system performance across 13 elements and 266 KPIs. Its four progressive assessment levels support evaluation of management practices and encourage the development of more effective operational and organizational arrangements.

The third edition introduced revised guidance, additional KPIs, changes to the assessment structure and a new maritime security element. These developments strengthened the framework's focus on management-system evaluation and continuous improvement.

Effective implementation requires more than completing the self-assessment. It depends on the practical application of procedures, competent personnel, reliable technical systems, appropriate operational controls and evidence demonstrating that management arrangements are working as intended.

Assessment

Evaluate the relevant TMSA elements and KPIs against the company's actual management arrangements.

Evidence

Support assessment decisions with appropriate records and evidence of implementation.

Improvement

Identify weaknesses and establish practical actions to strengthen management-system performance.

Management Review

Monitor results and maintain continuous evaluation of the effectiveness of the management system.

PAMS Pacific Admiralty Maritime Services

PAMS Pacific Admiralty Maritime Services is an independent marine technical consultancy based in Manila, Philippines. The company specializes in marine surveying, FPSO/SPM technical engineering and maritime regulatory compliance.

Its technical consultancy activities include support relating to RightShip RISQ 3.2, OCIMF SIRE 2.0 and TMSA, within the agreed scope of each assignment.

Independent technical consultancy: PAMS provides objective marine surveying, engineering assessment and regulatory compliance support. Its role is advisory and technical; responsibility for the operator's management systems, self-assessment and regulatory submissions remains with the relevant company.

Technical Content Review

Technical Subject

OCIMF Tanker Management and Self Assessment, Third Edition (TMSA 3), including its assessment elements, KPIs, assessment levels and continuous-improvement principles.

Review Focus

TMSA 3 structure, management-system assessment, evidence review, operational implementation, tanker management and the relationship with SIRE 2.0.

Reference basis: This article provides a general technical explanation of TMSA 3. Operators should consult the applicable OCIMF publication and current programme guidance when conducting an actual self-assessment.

TMSA 3 Frequently Asked Questions

What does TMSA stand for?

TMSA stands for Tanker Management and Self Assessment. It is an OCIMF programme that enables tanker operators to evaluate their management systems against defined KPIs and supporting best-practice guidance.

What is TMSA 3?

TMSA 3 is the third edition of OCIMF's Tanker Management and Self Assessment programme. It was published in April 2017 and introduced revised guidance, additional KPIs and a new maritime security element.

How many elements are included in TMSA 3?

TMSA 3 contains 13 numbered elements. Element 6 is divided into Element 6 and Element 6A, with Element 6A addressing mooring and anchoring operations.

How many KPIs are included in TMSA 3?

TMSA 3 contains 266 Key Performance Indicators (KPIs). This is 19 more than the previous edition and includes 85 newly introduced KPIs.

How many assessment levels does TMSA 3 have?

TMSA 3 uses four progressive assessment levels for its KPIs. The levels provide a framework for evaluating management practices from the minimum expectations through increasingly advanced stages.

What is the purpose of the TMSA 3 assessment levels?

The four levels provide a structured way to evaluate the development and maturity of management practices. The applicable expectations are defined by the individual KPI and its associated best-practice guidance.

What is new in TMSA 3 compared with TMSA 2?

TMSA 3 introduced expanded and revised best-practice guidance, additional KPIs, revised Elements 6 and 6A, an updated Environmental and Energy Management element, and a new Element 13 covering Maritime Security. It also removed the option to mark KPIs as not applicable.

What is Element 13 in TMSA 3?

Element 13 is Maritime Security. It was introduced in the third edition to address maritime security within the tanker management assessment framework.

What does Element 10 cover?

Element 10 covers Environmental and Energy Management. The third edition expanded the previous environmental management scope to incorporate energy-management considerations.

Can a KPI be marked as not applicable in TMSA 3?

No. The option to mark KPIs as not applicable was removed in TMSA 3. Operators should consult the applicable OCIMF guidance when determining how a particular KPI applies to their organization.

Is TMSA 3 a certification or statutory audit?

No. TMSA is a voluntary self-assessment framework. It is not a statutory certificate or substitute for mandatory audits, flag State requirements, classification requirements or applicable regulations.

Who is responsible for conducting the TMSA self-assessment?

The tanker operating company is responsible for its TMSA self-assessment, including the evaluation of management arrangements, assessment decisions and supporting evidence.

What evidence is required for a TMSA 3 assessment?

Evidence depends on the applicable KPI. It may include procedures, records, training documentation, operational reports, performance information, investigation findings and records demonstrating implementation and improvement.

What is the difference between TMSA 3 and SIRE 2.0?

TMSA 3 evaluates the company's management systems and organizational arrangements. SIRE 2.0 is a vessel inspection programme that evaluates vessel condition, operational practices and onboard performance during an inspection. The programmes are complementary but serve different purposes.

Does TMSA 3 replace the ISM Code?

No. TMSA 3 does not replace the ISM Code or any other statutory or regulatory requirement. Operators must continue to comply with all applicable mandatory maritime requirements.

How often should a tanker operator review its TMSA assessment?

Operators should maintain their self-assessment as part of their management-system review and improvement process. The frequency and timing of updates should be considered against current OCIMF programme guidance and changes to the company's management arrangements.

How can independent consultants support TMSA improvement?

Independent technical consultants can assist with agreed-scope gap assessments, management-system reviews, evidence evaluation and corrective-action reviews. The operator remains responsible for its TMSA self-assessment and any official submission.

Does PAMS provide TMSA technical consultancy?

PAMS Pacific Admiralty Maritime Services provides independent marine technical consultancy and regulatory compliance support, including TMSA-related technical assessment and review within the agreed project scope.

Official OCIMF TMSA 3 Reference

The TMSA 3 programme and its detailed assessment requirements are published by the Oil Companies International Marine Forum (OCIMF). Operators should refer to the official publication and applicable programme guidance when preparing or updating their self-assessments.

OCIMF — Tanker Management and Self Assessment, Third Edition

OCIMF — TMSA 3 Frequently Asked Questions

OCIMF — TMSA 3 Fast Facts

This article is an independent technical overview. It is not an OCIMF publication and does not represent endorsement, approval or certification by OCIMF.

TMSA 3 Technical Consultancy and Compliance Support

PAMS Pacific Admiralty Maritime Services provides independent technical consultancy to support tanker operators with TMSA assessment, management-system reviews, evidence evaluation and continuous-improvement activities within the agreed consultancy scope.

Explore PAMS TMSA Consultancy

TMSA 3 Technical Reference Notice

This article provides a general technical overview of OCIMF TMSA 3, its assessment structure and its role in tanker management. The detailed requirements applicable to an individual assessment are those contained in the relevant OCIMF publication and current programme guidance. This article does not replace the official TMSA 3 publication, statutory requirements, flag State requirements, classification requirements or company procedures.

Blog Articles

Back to content